← All articles

Blog

Marketplace Analytics: Which Channel Actually Makes Money?

Revenue on Shopee, Tokopedia or TikTok Shop is not profit. See how to compare marketplace channels on true margin after fees, shipping, returns and ads.

5 min read
  • mid
  • marketplace

The short answer

You find out which channel makes money by comparing contribution margin per channel, not sales. That means revenue minus product cost, marketplace fees, promotions, shipping you subsidise, returns, ads and the staff time the channel eats. Each seller center reports its own slice of this. None of them reports it the same way, and none of them knows your product cost. So the answer almost always has to be assembled in one place you control: a well-built spreadsheet at small scale, an ERP or reporting layer later.

Why seller-center numbers mislead

Shopee, Tokopedia, TikTok Shop and Lazada each give you dashboards. They are useful for traffic, conversion and best-selling products inside that channel. They have three limits for the “who makes money” question:

  • Different definitions. “Sales” may be before or after discounts, vouchers, or cancellations. Compare like with like before you compare channels.
  • No cost of goods. The platform does not know what you paid for the item, so it cannot show margin.
  • Partial costs. Fees, ads, affiliate payouts and shipping subsidies appear in different reports, often at different times than the order.

Marketplace tooling also keeps changing. The Tokopedia and TikTok Shop combined Seller Center was reported as launched in June 2025, so your reports and menus may differ from older guides. Verify in your seller center what each report actually includes.

What to count, per channel

LineWhere it comes fromCommon trap
Net salesOrder report, after discounts and cancellationsCounting orders that were later returned
Product costYour own purchasing recordsUsing last month’s cost for old stock
Platform feesSettlement or income reportsFees show up at payout, not at order
Programme feesFree shipping, promo and similar programmesForgotten because they are opt-in
Shipping subsidyCourier invoices vs what the buyer paidWeight disputes and courier adjustments
Returns and refundsReturn reportsCounted as a sale, then as a loss, or not at all
Ads and affiliateAds dashboard, creator payoutsSpend booked monthly, sales booked daily
Handling and packingYour warehouse or staff costTreated as free

Fees differ, and they move

Fee structures vary by channel, category and seller type, and platforms change them. A June 2025 Katadata Databoks summary estimated Shopee’s total seller fees at 2.5% to 17.4%, Tokopedia at 5% to 15.8%, Lazada at 4.25% to 18.24% and Blibli at 2.5% to 8%, depending on components such as commission, Mall fees and optional programmes. It also noted a Rp1,250 per-order processing fee on Shopee from 20 July 2025. A May 2026 Bisnis.com report compared mandatory fees on TikTok Shop and Shopee, so the picture has shifted since then.

Treat these as indicative only. The range is wide because of category and programme choices, which is exactly why a blended “marketplace costs about X%” rule of thumb is dangerous. Check the current fee page in each seller center and keep the date you checked.

A simple worked example

Take one product, sold at the same Rp200,000 price on two channels, with Rp110,000 product cost. Channel A has lower fees but you offer subsidised shipping and see more returns. Channel B has higher fees but buyers pay shipping and return less. Depending on the numbers, B can leave more money per order despite the higher headline fee. (This is an illustration of the method, not data about any real channel.) The point: only the full per-order calculation shows it.

Look at more than margin

  • Margin per order and per unit, by SKU and channel. A channel that wins on one product may lose on another.
  • Return and cancellation rate by channel.
  • Payout timing. Money that arrives later costs you working capital.
  • Ad dependency. If sales vanish when ads stop, the margin was rented.
  • Customer value. Repeat buyers, and whether you can reach them, differ by channel. On marketplaces you generally cannot take the customer relationship off the platform.
  • Stock risk. A channel that is hard to forecast may cause stock-outs elsewhere.

Spreadsheet or system?

A spreadsheet is fine while you have one or two channels and a few hundred orders a week. It breaks when you have many SKUs, bundles, several warehouses, or when someone must re-key downloads every week. At that point the cost is not the tool, it is stale numbers and decisions made on them.

The usual path is to bring orders, settlements and product costs into one system so each order carries its cost and fees. An ERP such as Odoo can hold product costs, sales orders and accounting; getting marketplace orders and settlements into it needs a connector, middleware or a custom build, each with its own cost and upkeep. Specialised marketplace management tools are another option. Compare what each vendor’s own pages state and run a trial on real data before committing.

What goes wrong

  • Settlement mismatches. The payout rarely equals the sum of orders; reconciling takes real effort.
  • Cost data is wrong. Reports are only as good as your product cost, which many sellers have never cleaned.
  • Rule changes. Fees, programmes and API access rules change; reporting built on them needs maintenance.
  • Over-precision. Allocating shared costs (rent, staff) per channel invites argument. Start with direct costs, and add the rest later.

When to get help

Consider outside help if you cannot say your margin per channel within a day or two of month end, if finance and operations show different sales totals, or if you are about to open another channel and want it measured properly from the start.

If you want to talk it through, Teknologia Solutions offers a no-charge conversation about your channels, your data and whether an ERP-based approach makes sense. No obligation, and we will tell you if a spreadsheet is enough.


Sources: Katadata Databoks, estimated seller fees June 2025; Bisnis.com, May 2026; Kontan, Tokopedia and TikTok Shop Seller Center. Fees and programmes change often; verify against each marketplace’s official seller center before deciding.